Dr Andrea Teng, Prof Tony Blakely, Prof Michael Baker, Prof Diana Sarfati
In this Blog we discuss our recently published study that shows that infection from the bacteria Helicobacter pylori is the major driver of stomach cancer inequalities borne by Māori and Pacific peoples in NZ. We also discuss a possible next step which could be for one DHB to pilot a ‘test and treat’ screening programme that seems likely to help reduce such inequalities.
Māori and Pacific people have 3 to 6 times the rates of stomach cancer as NZ Europeans. These are some of the starkest relative inequalities between ethnic groups in New Zealand (1). This disparity is particularly concerning given poor stomach cancer survival. In 2013 the Ministry of Health reported that 80 Māori and 35 Pacific people died from stomach cancer, out of a total of 371 stomach cancer deaths. Although stomach cancer rates are declining here and around the world, we estimate that there would be up to 85 fewer deaths every year (61 Māori, 24 Pacific) if stomach cancer occurred in Māori and Pacific people at the same incidence as in European/Other. The majority of these deaths are probably preventable. While H. pylori is known to cause much of stomach cancer around the world, there has been speculation in NZ that high Māori and Pacific rates are not largely explained by differing rates of H. pylori. Our findings published in the journal Gastric Cancer this week underline H. pylori as the major driver of ethnic inequalities in stomach cancer (2) (http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10120-016-0671-8/fulltext.html). This new study has substantial implications for how we might address excess stomach cancer deaths by ethnicity and how we address stomach cancer risk for all New Zealanders.
There has been longstanding interest in reducing the high rates of stomach cancer in Māori (3). In the early 1980s H. pylori was identified (4) and subsequently recognised as a driver of ethnic differences (5). However, much attention has been given to a genetic risk of stomach cancer in some Māori whanau (6), with some commentators suggesting that the excess risk of stomach cancer may be largely due to this genetic mutation (7). In fact, the E-cadherin mutation does not explain many of the excess deaths in Māori and Pacific. Our new study clearly places H. pylori as the major driver of stomach cancer inequalities (2).
H. pylori is an infection that is normally acquired in childhood and passed down through families. It’s prevalence is associated with poverty and household crowding (8) and may be linked to these risk factors over generations; marking this infection with a historical legacy of poverty, crowding and colonisation. With today’s rise in homelessness and increasing rates of household crowding (9), particularly for the least well off, problems with housing affordability and child poverty have marked implications and can cast a very long shadow. Preventing children getting infected with H. pylori may be achievable through interventions to reduce household crowding and child poverty. Acquisition of H. pylori has declined in younger generations (10) but it will take decades to eradicate H. pylori at the current rate of decline.
Adults with chronic H. pylori infection are likely to be asymptomatic. Infection with H. pylori is treatable with triple therapy (two antibiotics and a proton pump inhibitor for 7-14 days) but this is not current practice for asymptomatic individuals. Several randomised controlled trials (RCT) have shown that testing and treating asymptomatic people is successful in reducing stomach cancer by about a third, although there is a wide range of uncertainty. The evidence is also unclear about the potential harms from screening, and this question needs further investigation, for example impacts on antibiotic resistance, and whether there is increased risk of any other complications.
The WHO and IARC Working Group (11) recommends that all countries consider including gastric cancer in their national cancer control programmes and that they conduct detailed assessments of its current and future human and economic impacts and of the potential value of prevention strategies. A cost-effectiveness analysis we have undertaken (under review with a journal) suggests that a targeted H. pylori test and treat screening programme is likely to be cost effective given current NZ settings particularly for Māori and Pacific adults (12). A watchful brief should therefore be placed on RCT evidence emerging from Europe, Asia and elsewhere that is evaluating the harms and benefits of H. pylori test and treat screening strategies. A screening feasibility pilot could be trialled in one DHB, for example to identify the highest risk groups (by age, sex and ethnicity) and the optimal test and treat strategy. Further information is also needed about the changing incidence of H. pylori, which groups are at highest risk of future stomach cancer, any changes in treatment success rates, and to identify the age that a test and treat strategy would be most beneficial.
In summary, we consider that stomach cancer inequalities should be better addressed in New Zealand. It may be time for health authorities to start considering piloting a H. pylori test and treat screening programme eg, in one DHB with relatively high proportions of Māori and Pacific peoples.
- Teng AM, Atkinson J, Disney G, Wilson N, Sarfati D, McLeod M, et al. Ethnic inequalities in cancer incidence and mortality: census-linked cohort studies with 87 million years of person-time follow-up. BMC Cancer. 2016;16(1):755.
- Teng AM, Blakely T, Baker MG, Sarfati D. The contribution of Helicobacter pylori to excess gastric cancer in Indigenous and Pacific men: a birth cohort estimate. Gastric Cancer. 2016.
- Stewart RJ, Stewart AW, Stewart JM, Isbister WH. Cancer of the Stomach in New Zealand: 1970–74. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Surgery. 1982;52(4):363-9.
- Warren JR, Marshall B. Unidentified curved bacilli on gastric epithelium in active chronic gastritis. Lancet. 1983;321(8336):1273-5.
- Fraser A, Scragg R, Metcalf P, McCullough S, Yeates N. Prevalence of Helicobacter pylori infection in different ethnic groups in New Zealand children and adults. Australian and New Zealand journal of medicine. 1996;26(5):646-51.
- Fraser AG. Helicobacter pylori: a historical perspective 1983–2003. N Z Med J. 2004;117(1194).
- Lowe I. Gastric cancer gene found in Maori families. New Scientist. 1998(2128). Accessed Nov 2016; https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg15821286-900-gastric-cancer-gene-found-in-maori-families/
- Baker MG, McDonald AM, Zhang J, Howden-Chapman P. Infectious Diseases Attributable to Household Crowding in New Zealand: A Systematic Review and Burden of Disease Estimate. Wellington: University of Otago / Ministry of Health; 2013.
- Amore K, Viggers H, Baker MG, Howden-Chapman P. Severe housing deprivation: The problem and its measurement, Official Statistics Research Series, 6. Available from www.statisphere.govt.nz. 2013.
- McDonald AM, Sarfati D, Baker MG, Blakely T. Trends in Helicobacter pylori infection among Maori, Pacific, and European Birth cohorts in New Zealand. Helicobacter 2015;20(2):139-45.
- International Agency for Research on Cancer, World Health Organization. Helicobacter pylori Eradication as a Strategy for Preventing Gastric Cancer. Lyon: International Agency for Research on Cancer; 2014.
- Teng AM, Kvizhinadze G, Nair N, McLeod M, Wilson N, Blakely T. Cost-effectiveness of Screening for H. pylori infection in a high risk population. (Under revision with a journal).